Monday, July 20, 2009

Movie 155: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (2009) by David Yates
starring Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint and Emma Watson


In a nutshell: On first impression, the second best entry in one of the most well-cared-for series of all time

Quick synopsis: Harry begins to work closely with Dumbledore to devise a plan of action for defeating Voldemort once and for all.

Content: I was worried about the remaining Potter movies after seeing Order of the Phoenix (OotP) two summers ago. OotP seemed rushed and I thought poor choices were made regarding what to leave in and what could be removed to keep the film around 2 hours. Although it looked great, the pacing sucked and it felt like the books had reached a size that the filmmakers could no longer handle. But since then I learned that a different screen writer was used for OotP than the one used for each of the first four films (Steve Kloves). So, I was hoping that by bringing back Kloves for Hlf-Blood Prince, all would be set right in the world of Harry Potter. Safely back in the hands of someone who knows the characters inside and out, HP6 gets everything right that OotP did not.

Some critics have grumbled that there is a lack of action in Half-Blood Prince, but if there was, I didn't really notice it. The big cave sequence at the end certainly seemed to pack enough action for my tastes. Some sequences are appropriately glazed over (the Quiddich stuff) and others are handled with great detail. Readers of the books know the sixth installment as the one that veers dangerously close to Dawson's Creek territory when it comes to romance. But director Yates doesn't make it sappy at all and keeps the mood very light with a surprising amount of sharp humor.

The new professor du jour is year six is Horace Slughorn, played by veteran Brit Jim Broadbent, whom I liked very much in Gangs of New York and Hot Fuzz. He didn't look anything like the professor that I had pictured, who was described as walrus-like, but I guess Wilford Brimley was unavailable (and not British). I liked Broadbent, though. And other than his appearance, I thought he fit the role quite well.

As everyone has come to expect, the visuals in the film are spectacular. And I noticed a level of detail absent since Alfonso Cuaron's series highpoint, Prisoner of Azkaban. The scene in the cave needed to blow people away and it did in a way that the climactic scene in the previous film did not. And the only problem I had with the film at all was what happens when Harry returns to the castle at the very end. Maybe I am confusing it with a scene from the final book, but I remember there being complete chaos going on around the castle as the final confrontation unfolds. But instead, everyone just seems to be watching the two old friends stare each other down. The scene works well enough, it's just not how pictured it, but you can't win 'em all.

The acting of the three kids has improved by leaps and bounds since the early films, and what a relief that is. It's much easier to forgive poor-ish acting by 10 year-olds than by 20 year-olds. Hermione still can't cry, but otherwise she is fine. The "kids" are surrounded by such an amazing supporting cast that it almost doesn't matter. It seems like every British actor worth knowing has taken a turn in the film. And it's almost criminal that people like Alan Rickman (Snape), Robbie Coltrane (Hagrid), David Thewlis (Lupin) and Timothy Spall (Peter Pettigrew) are given only a few minutes each, but it was necessary in order to squeeze them all in, and make sure that they remain in the series so that they do not come out of nowhere when they play significant roles in the finale.

I gotta mention the improvement in Helena Bonham Carter's character since the last film. You all know her from nearly every Tim Burton movie (I think they are married or something) and Fight Club. She was the perfect choice to play Bellatrix Lestrange, a shrieking, psychotic evil witch of the worst type. But in the last movie (her first appearance) it was barely even a character she was playing. All she did was cackle and look as crazy as possible. But her character is much better this time around. She still acts plenty crazy, but there is actually a person (albeit a crazy one) behind the sneering. She brings a menace to the screen that would make Gary Oldman (whose character happens to have been killed by Bellatrix in the previous movie) proud.

David Yates learned from his mistakes in HP5 and, while I had previously been hoping and praying that they would bring back Cuaron, or even bring in a Guillermo del Toro-level director to finish off the series, I now feel that Yates will do just fine. In the grand scheme of things, I rate Half-Blood Prince as the second best of the series thus far, behind Prisoner of Azkaban. For what it's worth, I would place Goblet of Fire third, Order of the Phoenix fourth, Chamber of Secrets fifth, Sorceror's Stone sixth. Now let's just hope the series manages to get even better for its final act which is supposed to be broken up into two films, so as not to leave anything out. Two more is fine by me.

Rolling rankings:
1. Punch-Drunk Love (#147)
2. In Bruges(#153)
3. Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (#155)
4. Star Trek (#146)
5. Up (#149)
6. I.O.U.S.A. (#150)
7. Burn After Reading (#152)
8. The Da Vinci Code (#151)
9. 21 (#154)
10. Star Trek: Generations (#148)

key:
masterpiece
excellent
good
mixed bag
more bad than good
garbage

Monday, June 22, 2009

Movie 154: 21

21 (2008) by Robert Luketic
starring Jim Burgess and Kevin Spacey


In a nutshell: I had issues reconciling the final product with the book on which it was supposedly based, but if you let it stand independently then its an acceptible, if predictable, Hollywood gambling movie

Quick synopsis: A team of MIT students devise a card counting strategy to beat the house at blackjack, and begin making a killing in Vegas. Things predictably go downhill from there.

Content: By popular request the blog is coming back to life after a lengthy 4th of July vacation. I expected the worst from 21. I had once seen the beginning on a plane before dozing off and my first impression was not a good one. But for some reason I decided to finally finish it.

21 is based on Bringing Down the House by Ben Mezrich, a non-fiction book. If you want a faithful adaptation of the book, stay far away from 21. It has been given the Hollywood treatment. The drama has been ramped up tenfold, with lots of confrontations between Rosa (Spacey) and Ben (Jim Sturgess). A pointless love story is even added for good measure. God forbid a movie about blackjack is absent a love story. The nameless casino security teams hot on their tale in the book is given not only a name, but a face as well. That of Larry Fishburne. And finally, twists are added at the end that has absolutely nothing to do with real life.

So we've established that 21 fails as an adaptation, but let's try to review it on its own merits. The verdict is that its really not as bad as I feared it would be. There are cliches galore. My favorite cliche used was the old "guy ditches his old nerdy friends for cool new friends, but the old friends eventually confront him about it." Off the top of my head, I remember this being used in Rookie of the Year and The Skulls, and I'm sure those weren't the only instances.

The movie is actually well made. It does a good job with Vegas and kept me on the edge of my seat a bit after I realized that we weren't following the book anymore. And believe it or not, I actually didn't see the final twist coming and found myself actually taking a side as far as who I wanted to come out on top. Maybe I'd call it a guilty pleasure, but it kinda worked for me.

Spacey is good as the morally corrupt prof, Fishburne is intimidating as an old-school Vegas enforcer, and Jim Sturgess is average looking enough for a role as an MIT whiz kid. Thank goodness they didn't cast a better looking guy cuz that probably would have drov me nuts. Sturgess's aw-shucks demeanor allowed me to buy into the humble genius he was selling to me. I also like Josh Gad who plays the small role of Ben's geeky best friend. I've seen this guy on Numb3rs and The Daily Show and he really has something original going for him. The weakest like was EASILY Kate Bosworth. The love story between her and Ben was the worst part of the entire movie. It was completely unneccessary in every way. There was no chemistry between the two actors and all their flirting seemed forced.

Another thing that bugged me was the movie's use of the famous "Monty Hall problem". For those of you who have never taken statistics, the problem is set on a game show (hosted by Mr. Hall) where there are three doors, one of which has a prize behind it. The contestant selects a door and Monty then reveals one of the two incorrect doors and gives the contestant an opportunity to switch between the two remaining doors in search of the prize. The question is: should the contestant switch?

Anybody worth their weight in graphing calculators knows that by switching, the contestant raises his odds of winning from 1/3 to 2/3. If you want to know why, write me an email. This is a movie blog, not a stats class.

So anyway, my problem with its use was that it's clearly meant to be something that gets the audience's attention when Ben gives the counterintuitive correct answer and then pulls them into this world of crazy math when he briefly explains its solution. But the problem is that it's a fairly common question to encounter in school. I have probably come across it at least 3 times in my academic career, so all it did was make me groan and feel like I was being patronized. I'm sure the writer was not a statitician and thought that he had found a really flashy, cool problem to use, but it's not.

So, don't rush out and rent 21, but don't be afraid to leave it on if you encounter it on cable. It's fine but it's not good. I didn't appreciate the way it was marketed to me as being based on the book when in reality the only thing they had in common were MIT students playing blackjack, but if you can look past the false advertising (or if you haven't even read the book) then by all means check 21 out.

My last complaint is about the book itself. As I said before, it is called Bringing Down the House, but after this movie came out, I saw a new edition of the book rebranded as 21! Shameless.

Rolling rankings:
1. Punch-Drunk Love (#147)
2. In Bruges(#153)
3. Star Trek (#146)
4. Up (#149)
5. I.O.U.S.A. (#150)
6. Burn After Reading (#152)
7. The Da Vinci Code (#151)
8. 21 (#154)
9. Star Trek: Generations (#148)
10. Bottle Shock (#145)

key:
masterpiece
excellent
good
mixed bag
more bad than good
garbage